Saturday, March 1, 2008

Review #9 - Beaujangles

Thursday February 28, 2008
Caesar Salad at Beaujangles
Hobart, Tasmania


Being a Thursday, it was the day for our regular lunch date at Liveat in the Elizabeth St Mall. However Hobart, being its usual unpredictable self, turned on a typical winter's day complete with mountain snow and heavy rain, somewhat uncharacteristically in February. Liveat being a takeaway-style establishment with mostly outdoor seating didn't seem as attractive as normal.

Not to be outdone, Jeremy and I regrouped and booked a table at Beaujangles, a little further down the mall, with lots of indoor seating and an electric fireplace. Since it was Caesar Salad Thursday, I seized the opportunity before me and ordered the caesar salad.

For the benefit of qey (see comments on Review #4) the menu description simply said:

Caesar Salad (no egg)

Sorry it's not more interesting!

To make up for the lack of textual description, I have this photo for posterity. Note the lovely little school of anchovies gathered on the side of the bowl. If you look closely at the bottom of the bowl at the front, you might catch sight of the bonus piece of bacon that I discovered lurking under the edge after I took the photo.


I'll start by saying that overall it was a very nice salad. Not the best I've had, but better than most. I scored it a full point for presentation, as it looked very appetising. The service was good, so that gets a full point as well.

The ingredients scored quite well. There was no egg, but as it was advertised this way, it did not lose any score for that. In general the ingredients were good, except for the cheese, which while correct in being Parmesan, was the cheap supermarket variety that you don't expect on a $14.90 salad. Also, the dressing was quite sparse. These two factors resulted in the loss of half a point for ingredients.

The taste scored a healthy 3 out of 4 points. The bacon was very tasty as were the anchovies. I think the anchovies rescued it slightly, since the dressing let it down a little. Can I go on a bit more about the anchovies? They were divine!

Lastly we get to value for money. This only scored half a point, as at $14.90 for a basic salad without egg and chicken, it's a bit pricey. The quality of the Parmesan was an influence here as well.

So, getting down to business, this one scored 8 out of 10. Overall, it was an enjoyable lunch.

Score Summary
Taste:
3
Ingredients:
2.5
Presentation:
1
Service:
1
Value for Money:
0.5

Total:

8/10

Review Score List

Sorted by Total Score



 TasteIngredientsPresentationServiceValue for MoneyTotal
Sals on the Square4311110
Elaia42½1119½
Segreto331119
The Stables3½2½1119
elfresco3½31½½8½
Beaujangles32½11½8
Pancake Parlour42½1½08
Shoreline3½2½½½½7½
Berwick Inn31½½117
Blue Skies2½1½1117
Liveat32½1½7
The Boulevard32½0106½
C Bar2½2½½½06
New Sydney2½½1116
Zeps Cafe21½½116


Sorted Alphabetically

 TasteIngredientsPresentationServiceValue for MoneyTotal
Beaujangles32½11½8
Berwick Inn31½½117
Blue Skies2½1½1117
The Boulevard32½0106½
C Bar2½2½½½06
Elaia42½1119½
elfresco3½31½½8½
Liveat32½1½7
New Sydney2½½1116
Pancake Parlour42½1½08
Sals on the Square4311110
Segreto331119
Shoreline3½2½½½½7½
The Stables3½2½1119
Zeps Cafe21½½116

Review #8 - Shoreline Hotel

Monday February 11, 2008
Chicken Caesar Salad at the Shoreline Hotel
Howrah, Tasmania


It was a large family gathering that called us to the Shoreline Hotel on Monday, February 11, 2008. The coming Thursday (14th) would mark the 60th wedding anniversary of Julianne's maternal grandparents. Other festivities were planned for Thursday, so Julianne's grandparents' extended family outing was held on the Monday.

After the meal, we recorded a very brief review. Here's the edited transcript:

JEREMY: Shoreline Hotel, 11th of February 2008...Chicken caesar salad – no croutons. What’s your score for taste?

JULIANNE: 3½

JEREMY: 3½ out of 4. Ingredients out of 3?

JULIANNE: Egg was boiled not poached...So I’d deduct ½ a mark for that. Everything else about the ingredients was good.

JEREMY: ...Presentation?

JULIANNE: Presentation – didn’t like the skewers. ½ a mark.

JEREMY: ½ for presentation. Um, value for money?

JULIANNE: [Indistinct]

JEREMY: ½ for that...And that gives us just service.

JULIANNE: [Indistinct]

JEREMY: Meh…½ for that as well. 7½. Is that 7½ then?

JULIANNE: Yep.

JEREMY: 7½ out of 10.

On a somewhat amusing side note, when we were discussing the service after the recording I said a little too loudly that I thought the service sucked. And yes, the waitress was right behind me when I said it. Oops.

Score Summary
Taste: 3.5
Ingredients: 2.5
Presentation: 0.5
Service: 0.5
Value for Money: 0.5
 
Total: 

7½/10

Review #7 - Segreto

Friday December 21, 2007
Tasmanian Char-Grilled Bacon Salad at Segreto
North Hobart, Tasmania


Segreto is one of our favourite restaurants. found in North Hobart, it's owned by Marty Zucco whose daughter is also gluten intolerant. They provide a number of gluten-free options, including pizzas.

One of the menu options is the Tasmanain Char-Grilled Bacon Salad, which is effectively a caesar salad with a spiffy name.

On the taste front, Julianne was heading towards a score of 4 out of 4 to begin with, but when she got into it, it slipped a little. Some of the lettuce left a bitter after taste, and she found the dressing a bit too creamy which meant she couldn't actually finish the salad. Apart from those two minor quibbles, it tasted very nice.

She couldn't fault the ingredients. All the core ingredents of a caesar salad were present. it came with anchovy dressing instead of actual anchovies, but we can't mark it down for that.

Everything else scored 1 out of 1. The service, as always, was excellent. Marty Zucco is an attentive and amicable host.

Score Summary
Taste: 3
Ingredients: 3
Presentation: 1
Service: 1
Value for Money: 1
 
Total: 

9/10

Thursday, February 28, 2008

Review #6 - Elaia

Saturday December 15, 2007
Cos Salad at Elaia
Launceston, Tasmania


On the way to visit my step-sister Michelle in George Town, we met up with her in Launceston for lunch.

Unfortunately we didn't take any notes, but then we really didn't need to. We'd previously been noting things that were wrong with caesar salads, and with this one there just wasn't anything bad to say.

The salad was so good and so nice that it lost only half a point, and that was because of the pepper on it. Julianne was quite willing to give this one a perfect score if it came without pepper.

While there were no optional anchovies - only anchovy dressing - we can't mark it down for that.

Elaia's Cos Salad is easily the best caesar salad yet. Very highly recommended.

Score Summary
Taste: 4
Ingredients: 2.5
Presentation: 1
Service: 1
Value for Money: 1
 
Total: 

9½/10

Review #5 - New Sydney Hotel

Wednesday November 28, 2007
Chicken Caesar Salad at the New Sydney Hotel
Hobart, Tasmania


Julianne and I went along to Big Laughs in the Little Pub at the New Sydney to see some local comedians strut their funny stuff.

We decided to get there early and have a meal before the show. Once again, I recorded the review (in a very dodgy Irish accent to mark the fact we were in an Irish pub) on Julianne's mobile phone. Here's a tasty exerpt of what was said on the night:

We're in the New Sydney Hotel. Julianne's just had a chicken caesar salad and it wasn't very good, and we're about to find out just exactly why.

We’re gonna start out with a mark out of 4 for taste. Now, the big problem we have with it is that the taste wasn’t a caesar salad taste because of the ingredients – we’ll get to the ingredients shortly. But, as far as taste goes, it did taste quite reasonable – it just wasn’t the right taste. So...because it just wasn’t the right taste...she can’t mark it up at all. So it’s 2½ out of 4 for the taste.

Moving on to the ingredients...the ingredients were all wrong. The sauce was completely wrong. It was wrong sauce. There was no egg at all...The lettuce was wrong...There was extra spinach that shouldn’t have been there...[The cheese] was mozzarella not parmesan, so it was the wrong cheese. Cor blimey, was there anything that was alright in this thing? The anchovies – how were the anchovies?...The anchovies was
[sic] too small – she couldn’t find that. The bacon was good though wasn’t it?...OK – good bacon. Anything else good about it?...The chicken was good but it had weird spices on it so marked down for that...I’m thinkin’ here that the ingredients score is not going to be very high...[Julianne: ½ a point]...½ a point out of 3 for ingredients, oh my goodness. That’s for the bacon right, the ½ a point? OK.

Alright, so we’re currently sitting at 3 out of 7. It’s not looking good for the New Sydney here at all.

Next, we’re going on to presentation. The presentation from me looking at it – it looks very symmetrical. You had the four chicken pieces pointing in towards the middle there
[if memory serves correctly, this was accompanied by hand gestures]. Presentation was good...1 out of 1 for presentation.

...Now we’ve got value for money...Good value for money. The cost of it was...
[here I turned and looked at the menu board behind me]...$14.50, and quite a big bowl...so 1 out of 1 for that.

...What’s the last one? Service. Excellent service. 1 out of 1.

There we go – 6 out of 10 for the chicken caesar salad...no bonus point for croutons.

Score Summary
Taste: 2.5
Ingredients: 0.5
Presentation: 1
Service: 1
Value for Money: 1
 
Total: 

6/10

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Review #4 - Berwick Inn

Saturday November 4, 2007
Chicken Caesar Salad at the Berwick Inn
Berwick, Victoria


This time around Julianne and I were visiting her sister in Melbourne. We went to their local - the Berwick Inn - for dinner.

Once again, comments are minimal.

The bacon came in strips/rashers rather than the usual crispy diced pieces, and it was hard to cut in the bowl.

The anchovies on the other hand were sliced into small pieces and hard to find.

The chicken was on skewers and hard to eat.

The dressing was watery and tasteless.

To prevent this entry from devolving into one big negative review, there were positives. The lettuce and the egg were good, and it did taste pretty nice.

Score Summary
Taste: 3
Ingredients: 1.5
Presentation: 0.5
Service: 1
Value for Money: 1
 
Total: 

7/10